All-Americans, All-Conference
| All-ACCAC | P | Year | All-Region I (DII Post -2002) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Reeve (2nd team) | OF | 2022 | Alex Reeve |
| *Season canceled due to COVID-19 | 2021 | ||
| Seaon halted due to Coronavirus | 2020 | ||
| P | 2019 | Jaden Placencio | |
| Ryann Holmes (1st team) Player of the Year 3rd Team All-American | IF | 2018 | Ryann Holmes |
| Samantha Quezada (3rd team) | UTIL | 2018 | |
| P | 2018 | Gabby Lopez | |
| Lindsey Paboucek (3rd team) | OF | 2017 | Lindsey Paboucek |
| Raychele Hernandez (3rd team) | OF | 2017 | |
| P | 2017 | Emerald Grijalva | |
| C | 2017 | Leighann Ballesteros | |
| Kendra Whelan (2nd team) | IF | 2015 | Kendra Whalen |
| Kyleigh Hanson (3rd team) | OF | 2013 | Kyleigh Hanson |
| Jackie Aguilar (1st team) | P | 2013 | Jackie Aguilar |
| IF | 2013 | Morgan McVein | |
| Tiffanee Frampton (2nd Team) 2nd Team All-American | UT | 2011 | |
| Sara Sandoval (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | OF | 2010 | Sara Sandoval |
| Tiffanee Frampton (1st Team) | P/IF | 2010 | Tiffanee Frampton |
| Shannon Dukes (2nd Team) | P | 2010 | Shannon Dukes |
| Bailey Blake (2nd Team) | IF | 2010 | Bailey Blake |
| Sara Sandoval (2nd Team) | OF | 2009 | Sara Sandoval |
| Krystal Ruiz (2nd Team) | P | 2008 | Krystal Ruiz |
| Theresa Tautinez (2nd Team) | IF | 2008 | Theresa Tautinez |
| Emily Farrier (3rd Team) | UT | 2008 | |
| Jessica DeFreitas (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | IF | 2007 | Jessica DeFreitas |
| Natalie Bejarano (2nd Team) | C | 2007 | Natalie Bejarano |
| Stephanie Bisgard (2nd Team) | OF | 2007 | Stephanie Bisgard |
| Amanda Hess (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | P | 2006 | Amanda Hess |
| Natalie Bejarano (2nd Team) | C | 2006 | Natalie Bejarano |
| Lisa Parks (1st Team) | IF | 2005 | Lisa Parks |
| Evonne Corona (3rd Team) | 2005 | Evonne Corona | |
| 2005 | Valarie Villela | ||
| Laura Chomokos (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | P | 2004 | Laura Chomokos |
| Sheaya Blanton (3rd Team) | 2004 | Sheaya Blanton | |
| IF | 2004 | Ashley Wisecarver | |
| Laura Chomokos (2nd Team) | P | 2003 | Laura Chomokos |
| Kristin Hardy (2nd Team) | IF | 2003 | Kristin Hardy |
| Ashley Wisecarver (2nd Team) | IF | 2003 | Ashley Wisecarver |
| 2003 | Christina Pesquiera | ||
| Sarah Golob (1st Team) | IF | 2001 | Sarah Golob |
| Jennifer Duke (1st Team) | OF | 2001 | Jennifer Duke |
| Monique Woodmansee (2nd Team) | P | 2001 | |
| Kellie Pebler (2nd Team) | OF | 2001 | |
| Jennifer Axtell (3rd Team) | 2001 | ||
| Monique Woodmansee (1st Team) | P | 2000 | |
| Lisa Wangler (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | UT | 2000 | |
| Cara Shinjo (2nd Team) | UT | 2000 | |
| Christina Underhill (2nd Team) | OF | 1999 | |
| Raquel Mead (3rd Team) | P | 1999 | |
| Raquel Mead (3rd Team) | P | 1998 | |
| Evona Morales (3rd Team) | UT | 1998 | |
| Cari Matthews (3rd Team) | 1998 | ||
| Shelley Arredondo (2nd Team) | 1995 | ||
| Stephanie Rector 2nd Team All-American | INF | 1993 | |
| Julie Young 1st Team All-American | INF | 1984 | |
| Kim Bickford 2nd Team All-American | P | 1981 | |
| Lisa Clinchy 1st Team All-American | 1980 | ||
| Suzie Pierson | 3B | 1979 | |
| Sheryle Nobley | OF | 1979 | |
| Jean Cochran | OF | 1979 | |
| Judy Crouse | P | 1979 | |
| Nancy Palmer | 1B | 1978 | |
| Gail Weigert | OF | 1978 |